The Surge 2 is, thematically, an even harder game to wrap my head around than The Surge 1.

We are dropped into the setting as an unnamed, player-insert, created character. Woken up from a Coma during a prison outbreak within a walled city named Jericho.

The city is quarantined due to exposure to the nano-machines outbreak, which formed the major 3rd act reveal of the first game. In certain localities, Human consciousness being subsumed into the nano-machine swarm was the ultimate result of the CREO corporation's project ReSolve and project Utopia. The spread of the nano-machines being treated as a plague by the A.I.D., functionally the state government police force. Who have put the city into a military-enforced quarantine. The Exo-Suit we steal from the Jericho City Police Department is no longer a horrific surgery, but a seamless, and permanent, nano-machine integration. Upon breaking out of prison, the first person we meet is a recruit for a local religion called Children of The Spark, who seek to become one with the nanomachines. And all of this is communicated within a few minutes of the start of the game.

As a game, The Surge 2 is far improved above the original. Combat is smoother, and faster, and better communicates the meters of the stability/stagger system as it relates to the flow of combat. As a result, they are far more confident in their encounter design. Placing more enemies arranged in unique ways, confident in the player having the tools needed to find a way through the challenge.

The resource management is also far improved. The starting healing item injection has been changed from a broad array of different options with limited uses to a few upgradable items that will store charges for future use based on your performance in combat. Excess energy from your skill in combat being saved as healing for future battles. Even leveling up using tech-scrap has been streamlined. The collectibles scrap items you collect around the world can all be cashed and banked with two buttons at the medbay checkpoints. 

It should be said here that, as a quarantine story released in 2019, The Surge 2's story is just prior to the global Covid pandemic and social distancing lockdowns. It is clear from audio logs at the start that we are expanding the themes of corporate greed, social engineering, and religious posturing, into further themes of government surveillance and abuse of authoritarian power. But media prior to the 2020s was frequently enamored with post-apocalyptic stories, often fueled by zombie disease outbreaks and city-wide quarantines.

It was a common thematic trend for a long time, holding long-lived popularity among Young Adult fiction like The Hunger Games, and prestige television like The Walking Dead. These settings were seen as fantastical, because there was generally widespread trust in public health systems, which people believed would keep society safe. Since covid, however, that trust has been completely lost. The pandemic helped paranoid conspiracy theorists control a narrative of distrust in public health, fueled by the burden public health initiatives were taking on people's mental health and economic security. Conservative grifters spun these narratives into distrust of the democrats for political gamesmanship. Culminating in prominent and unqualified members of these conspiracy communities being elevated to positions of authority in public health offices. For example, RFK Jr. being made the Secretary of Health. 

Despite having no doctorates in medicine, and a history of causing measles outbreaks in Samoa and other regions, because of his anti-vaccine, anti-autism campaigns. Which has now also become a problem in the US.

So, in turn, liberals and leftists no longer have trust in public health due to corporate favoritism given to restrictive insurance companies, the culling of benefits in the Affordable Care Act marketplace, and passing laws restricting health services for women and trans people generally.

Public health messaging by the federal Department of Health in the USA is now a weekly affair of advocating for radical fad diets and other conspiracies. Less helpful than the average Men's Health article online.

Surge 2 was not equipped to handle the modern body politik, but rather was following storytelling trends. Choosing to use a semi-fraudulent pandemic as the metaphor for corruption in Government and conspiracy with the Tech industry. A time when a global pandemic was unthinkable. Before we had the inverse. An actual pandemic that was real, but due to government corruption, large swaths of the population believed it was a conspiracy. 

This is all to say that the themes of The Surge 2 are far more messy than The Surge 1. Playing it today, discussion of these themes are equally more messy than they were in the environment the game originally released in. And my desire to talk about the games as a Mecha Action Game series are plagued by that baggage.

So, if you'll permit me, I would like to forgo the socio-political discussion except where it is necessary for discussing the fantastical ideas presented in the science-fiction of the setting. So that I might sing the game’s praises for its design and its intrigue as a narrative. 

Or, at least that is what I would like to have said. But over time, it's clear that themes of the game are inherently socio-politically inspired, yet haphazard in execution.

Let's start with my build. Surge 2 has done away with the weapon-use proficiency scaling, unlock the player ability to quickly switch weapons mid-combat, and thus allowing the player to better play around with the different damage types and status effects the game has to offer. Armors now come with set bonuses on top of their regular stats, which encourages players to build collections of different rigs as tools in the toolkit. As opposed to merely finding ways to min-max your attack speed and impact by mixing different pieces.

I immediately like this system far more, because it feeds into the appeal of designing a custom mech. Choosing either to go for a full set, or to go for two effects of a half-set makes for interesting decision making. And the set bonuses actively change the flow of combat. One bonus allows you to perform limb-cuts without energy, thus reserving it for health items or other special moves. Or another set that heals the player upon charging a battery. Encouraging you to tank damage and keep attacking, while relying on your high-stability to keep you up.

The level design for Surge 2 has also changed dramatically. Whereas Surge 1 was a linear progression through a massive business park, Surge 2 goes for a hub & spoke approach. The central city map navigates to more isolated levels, which serve as bespoke setpieces and boss fights. Though the main path still guides the player through a linear sequence of events. I imagine that Surge 1 originally desired a more open concept like this. Players could navigate between areas at any time, but the level design didn't motivate a metroidvania style exploration. Surge 2 succeeds at this integration more than the original. But it won't feel fully realized unless you engage with the game's optional side-quests. 

Which brings me to the character writing of the game. Surge 1 had impressively nuanced character writing for the player who chose to pay attention. From critiquing the player's subconscious assumptions about who an action game protagonist can be. To strangers forming familial relationships with machines. To friends losing their identity and free will to the invasive technologies of the corporate overlords. It is a note of the game that I failed to appreciate in Surge 1; only revealed now by the caricatures of the Surge 2.

From the very first boss, Little Johnny, being the stereotype of a greedy, misogynistic mob-boss, presented as a literal adult-baby by way of the literary trope of “Fat = Evil”. Betrayals and double-crosses by religious fanatics and private mercenaries. Everyone giving you the stink-eye while acting tough. Everyone not acting as a faceless goon for the government is acting merely out of selfish profit. 

Even the player character, now a created character rather than having a bespoke direction, is flattened to heroics or randomly being an asshole. The first game's protagonist, Warren, could be played as more or less cruel, but the setting earned it. My most charitable reading is that there is a tacit assumption of a Hobbesian world view of human nature. That in an anarchic situation this is just how people would act. Violently driven to secure whatever meager resources they can, without cooperation nor care for others. Which is simply not a world view I share. In desperate situations, it is typically one’s need to love & support others that drive them to weigh resources against morality. Yet still striving to do right by people in most circumstances.

Warren, however, is a different matter entirely. He features prominently in this game as a character called “Stranger”. Though he all but announces “I am Warren, the protagonist of the first game!” if you are familiar with Surge 1. Yet in a complete betrayal of the narrative arc of the first game, Warren here is presented wearing the modern Exo-Rig and not using his wheelchair.

In my opinion, this decision to turn Warren into an action star hero without his wheelchair completely mutes the thematic arc of the first game. Whereas the whole of Surge 1 developed an ethic of seeing morality in everyone, of not seeing the human condition as a problem to be fixed. Surge 2 is only interested in saying, “the suit gives you super strength, and now you can be a hero.” Rarely with some lip-service to the idea that the exo-rig also destroys your privacy rights by recording and reporting all of your thoughts and experiences to the company and the government. Usually played for laughs in audio logs or from a robot vending machine. 

The moral struggle at the center of Surge 1 is blatantly ignored by Surge 2, via a character assassination of the first game protagonist's story.

Which puts me right back where we started. The Surge 2 is a thematically messy game. By lingering on the basic video game review, I was trying to find the pieces that would connect the dots and answer this question. What does it want to communicate with its setting and its story?

The closest I can start to surmise is through who the game presents as heroes, and who it presented as villains. Despite the created character player-avatar there is one, immutable fact of the protagonist. They were in a coma, and they were being kept not in a hospital, but a prison.

The coma is the closest thing to the disability narrative of the first game, and the prison break seems apt for commentary on the prison industrial complex. But this is only expanded by paralleling the setting with the independent military organization that is administrating the state's city quarantine. AID, the acronym meaning Attack Insurgency and Disease, demonstrates a police force with a very clear ideology. Insurgency, resistance against the state on the part of the people, must be attacked. Disease, the nanomachines which have infected the people, must be attacked. Including a particular child we follow throughout the story, Athena, who we witness also breaking out of a kind of prison… The methodology of AID attacking and kidnapping people makes it clear that both illness and political dissent are being treated as harmful to the public good.

I must remind myself, once again, that this game predates the current ICE administration, and their policies of attacking people in public and stealing people, including children, off of the streets.

Athena, the little black girl we've been trying to save, is the granddaughter of Jonah Gutenberg, the CEO of the tech company CREO which made this disaster in the first game. Much like the initial reveal of the wheelchair at the beginning of the first, this is Surge 2's attempt at wordlessly communicating a subconscious bias in its audience. Of course an older white man may have a black granddaughter. You forget that anyone can fall in love with anyone. That being mixed race is commonplace. And had Athena been made the protagonist, Surge 2 might have double-featured in my Africana Games series.

Surge 2, also, wants to have the themes of exposing and confronting implicit bias. That theme pops up on rare occasion throughout, even at the end of the game. So it makes me wish the game's own character writing knew how to self-examine in the same way it calls the player to. 

There is a certain character that you meet after a big moment in the game. A big moment that sort of sets you down the path to the final boss. The character's name is Okunji Saint-Croix.

He is madman introduced by having him shoot at the player while fighting off a pit full of nanite enemies. When you meet him, he introduces himself has a former professor at CREO Institute of Technology. He cackles between each sentence. He casually asks you to kill of the nanite-zombified enemies. (This is the narrative reason given for fighting human enemies now. In Surge 1 is was corporate brain-implants gone haywire. At the start of Surge 2 it was everyone being super excited to loot supplies. And now it's, verbatim, zombies.

If you have been watching this series and now much of me, you may not know I'm a stickler about zombies. I'm a Haitian American, and almost no one knows the history of how the Hollywood movie monster The Zombie came into the media landscape. I'll save you the details here, but it's an ugly and racist history.

Okunji, usually written Okonji, is a Nigerian name from the Igbo culture. It's usually a family name instead of a personal name, however. Now a lot of the culture that survived the slave trade was Yoruba culture, nearby the same region but different cultures. So we'll give them a solid C+ for their efforts. The last name, however, Saint-Croix, is clearly French.

So they are signaling that the character is either from Louisiana/New Orleans, or is Haitian. They are immediately invoking the religion of voodoo with this choice by going to zombies, but, as always, only present the movie monster. Not a real religious concept. 

Okunji is also afflicted by nanites, and that's why he's crazy. But he's a special kind of crazy.

The character's voice actor is not listed in the credits. So until I hear otherwise, this feels like a situation where one of the crew already signed on did a strangely affected black-cent and called it a day.

And that is the issue with this game, over Surge 1. Despite being a better crafted game, though with the caveat that only about half the bosses were designed well. It shows a deep disinterest in telling a story that is introspective. Government bad. Cults bad. And there's some nods to a metaphor that religion and government are like prisons. The ghost of a story about prisons being a dehumanizing institution and giving people second chances. But in a vague way. Seeing my black player-avatar and Athena together constantly dangling the carrot of profundity, only to snatch it away again. 

The decision to team up with the former CEO of CREO, presented unironically as a tech CEO super genius, feels so antithetical to the story of the first game. As such, Surge 2 presents that a Hobbesian, or more Libertarian, notion of self-interest or selfishness, even at the cost of self destruction, is the only motivation. And the solution is another strong-willed individual pursuing self-interest.

The most charitable reading I can provide is that the protagonist is selflessly trying to save a child, and the child is trying to actually set everyone in Jericho free without controlling them. The child treats all life as sacred without fail. But in saying that I can't shake the feeling that even this much is giving too much grace.

I wish I could bring these pieces together into a single frame. All I can do for now is ask…

So tell me kiddo, now that you can be a super strong cool guy with no down-sides thanks to the nanite powered super Exo-Rig, are you ready to get in the robot?