In the 2010s a peculiar trend arose in the Triple-A gaming space. Black protagonists were becoming included in major, mainstream video game franchises, but not the main characters of their own games. Rather, they were cloistered to the experimental “Standalone DLC Game.”

These games were 2012's Assassin's Creed 3 Lady Liberty (now called Liberation), 2013's Assassin's Creed IV Black Flag Freedom Cry, and 2017's Dishonered Death of the Outsider. As well as honorable mentions to 2014's The Last of Us Left Behind and 2017's Uncharted Lost Legacy, which feature girl and woman protagonists whose accompanying deuteragonists were black characters.

The Standalone DLC was a model of additional content meant to smooth over the growing gaps between major franchise releases while normalizing the significantly lower costs of digital distribution. Various studios also saw it as a lower-stakes way of experimenting with new gameplay designs or ways to reach a broader audience.

There is no doubt in my mind that, among the people who made these games, there is a wide swath of inspirations and intentions. Some motivated only by the marketing assumptions of player relatability only being possible with same-race and same-sex protagonists to the player. And some motivated by an honest desire among the developers to create diverse characters and tell different stories than one would typically find in their main-entry counterparts.

By covering these 5 games, I am conscious of the fact that I am breaking my own rules. These games, as dlc, are a priori optional experiences. These games, as dlc, are expansions on a piece of another, typically european or white male, protagonist's story. And the risk of wanting to include them in the Africana Games series, designed specifically to highlight stories which show black characters as the main characters in their own rights, is that they will fail to actually Standalone.

To be stories players would care about without first investing in the higher budget, higher propriety games that came before them.

That is why I am going to play them. And play them without having first experienced the franchises to which they belong, save for The Last of Us. To answer for myself if these Triple-A properties can be called Africana Games. Starting with:

-

Assassin’s Creed 3: Liberation Remastered

Up top, the reader should know that I am playing the remastered collection of Assassin's Creed 3 on the Playstation 5. Any improvements or changes to gameplay and presentation are thus not necessarily representative of how the games were originally released.

The opening menus first show the protagonist of AC 3 and Liberation standing side by side. And it is notable that due to Aveline not being dressed in the iconic widows-peaked hood of Assassin's Creed protagonists, her character design is far more distinctly of her era. Her leather armored waistcoat and tricorn hat immediately communicate the aesthetics of 18th century piracy. While her shoulder-long braids flowing behind her suggests the level of femininity and labor required to both be able to achieve those braids with curly hair, and to keep it such that her hair may not interfere with her work.

Immediately my general lore-awareness of the franchise from playing AC Origins and Odyssey gives the game's intro a notable point of discussion. The Animus, by Abstergo Corp, uses their fictional concept of “genetic memory” to create these simulations of the past. The opening cinematic is a fictional advertisement to the player suggesting that they, personally, are using the animus and playing through these events. Not a separate character in the lore of the series, but the player beyond the fourthwall. Therefore, Aveline de Grandpré is YOUR ancestor. (Though this initial impression is later undercut by plot developments.)

This can be taken two ways. The charitable reading is that this is a point of empathy. Acknowledging that Aveline could be the ancestor of anyone who may be playing the game to experience the fantasy. The uncharitable reading is that, using the demographics-centered industry convention of “relatability” as the metric, Ubisoft didn't expect anyone other than black people to be interested in playing. I, however, chose to accept this premise as a fantasy that this is one of my ancestors. A note that comes easily thanks to my Haitian roots.

Aveline's backstory is told quickly by a dream sequence. The day she was separated from her mother in the market. Witnessed a slave auction on the street. And was beaten by a militia man for mistakenly touching a white woman while searching for her mother. I found only one part of this premise hard to believe, and it is that a black mother would flippantly forget her child or let her run after a chicken in the streets in this environment. Even if she was a petite bourgeois, she would know to keep a vice grip on her children to prevent exactly this. 

Once the nightmare is ended,we catch up with Aveline as an adult. She has already become an assassin, and keeps this fact hidden from another petite bourgeois white woman who adopted her.

Now, before we move forward, let's address the language I'll be using through this review. I am going to be using racial identifying language throughout, as given the setting of the latter 18th century, the realities of slavery and racism-based class divides are the unavoidable dynamics of characters and plot. While I am a racial anti-realist, the reality of history is that people have lived for hundreds of years and do still live as though the categories created by racist, colonialist power dynamics are real.

If it makes you uncomfortable to hear a sentence like, “a white petite bourgeois woman adopted a black orphan,” you need to accept that discomfort, and move on to asking what it would take for this character dynamic to come about in this setting. Was Aveline truly adopted? Was she purchased to be a house slave only to luck into a house of abolitionists? These are the questions the story seeds in its opening acts.

The gameplay quickly opens up to introducing the three costumed personae that Aveline takes on throughout the game. The Lady is used for bribing officials and investigation. The Slave is used for infiltrating plantations for assassinations. And The Assassin is designed for the open world exploration, key missions, and combat. This espionage side of Assassin's Creed as a franchise lends a groundedness to the progression of the story. Which upon experiencing it here, I now understand why people lament its absence in the open-world oriented gameplay of Origins, Odyssey, and Valhalla.

And, it should be mentioned that the parkour gameplay is, as always, smooth, fast, and intuitive. Living up to the series reputation.

The story, however, shows the marks of its franchise with its first assassination. The year is 1763. The governor is working with a Spanish Templar called Rafael Joaquin de Ferrer. We are working with an accountant and Assassin's Brotherhood informant Gerard Blanc. Who are the templar? How did we join the brotherhood? These things don't need to be addressed because we are experiencing only fractions of a memory in a series you should already have played.

De Ferrer further convinces the governor to assist with their trading of rebellious slaves by warning him that what happened in Santo Domingo could happen here in this middling Louisiana city. Even though years are given throughout story segments, the exact years are unclear; it seems this was an attempt to reference the Haitian Revolution, but the setting is a couple decades too early. I'm also just unaccustomed to hearing how a Spanish person of the era might refer to Saint Domingue as a general word for the island. But it sounds strange to me since Santo Domingo is the capital city of the Dominican Republic, and the Dominicans wouldn't overthrow Spain until the 1820s, which is a few decades away from the current time period.

It is funny how just one sentence can lead me to worrying that the writers at Ubisoft didn't have a strong grasp of the history they were writing within. But what stood out to me is that the Governor character, in his dying breath, said he supported the templars to keep his town French. Which is a good note of shared historical conflicts across French colonial regions. The Louisiana Purchase was just at the start of the 19th century, and the question of whether the territory wanted to join the Americans was a live one. Which I'm sure was an understandable sentiment at Ubisoft Montreal, as Montreal and Quebec still have political conflicts over how best to preserve French culture today. While all sides share that goal of historical preservation, the conflicts are often split by a conservative, exclusionary nationalism.

Immediately after uncovering the plot and fleeing the governor's mansion, we rush out of town to The Bayou. But here is another cheeky time-skip. If the player isn't reading, the scene seems contiguous. But the animus tells us it is two years later, now 1765.

Upon entering the Bayou, our mysterious instructor Agaté sends us a letter to come and assist him. Saying, “May the Loas guide you swiftly,” had me shocked. The Loas are the pantheon of ancestor spirits worshipped in Haitian and Lousiana Voodoo. Only to immediately be made concerned by the wooden masks used to mark the path to his hideout. Are we taking inspiration from research or from tropes?

At Agate's base, he provides us with our next target, a person masquerading as Francois Makandal, and a poison blowdart. Which also leads me to thinking we are doing a hodgepodge of tribalist imagery. Makandal was a voudou priest, and part of a group called the Maroons. Essentially escaped or freed blacks who lived outside the French settled towns and cities to be free. Makandal was known for organizing slave revolts, as well as the use of poisons, but he was also highly mythologized immediately upon his death due to poor records and inconsistent details of the trial where he was put to death. It could be that he made poisons to kill the grand blanc slave owners. Or it could be that the religious ceremonies and rituals of voodoo were being treated as evil magic and poisoncraft. Francois Makandal was also mythologized as leading a massive band of maroons to genocide all the petite blanc, as well as for transforming into a fly just before he was executed and escaping.

In either case, Mackandal's execution made him a Martyr, and he would go on to inspire many Haitians to join the cause of revolution.

I took some time to explore Agaté's base, apparently earned myself a red check for not completing the mission in less than 2 minutes, and found a voodoo shrine above his home. Between a wooden mask of a woman and a man was a tapestry with the veve of Baron Samedi, who along with his wife Mama Brigette, are Loa who guard cemeteries. As well as see the recently diseased safe passage to the world of the dead. Occasionally believed also to provide healing to people who are severely ill, but not ready for death.

Papa Legba's Veve is carved into the door. Which is appropriate given Papa Legba's domain is doors, gates, and passageways. As well as being the bridge between humans and the spiritual world.

And a smaller shrine with the veve of Damballah Wédo and Ayida Wèdo, the sky and rainbow serpents who created the world and the Lwa. And it should be noted here that creation may have been done by Damballah Wédo, but that's not to say he is the religion's god figure. That would be Bondyè, or also called Olorun and Olodumarè. Who is much more distant from human affairs than the Loa.

But whereas I can point these things out, an ignorant player is mainly just encouraged to glance at them while they pass by in a rush. At this point, I'm keeping the game at arms length. But I am seeing some effort.

Then we save a group of Cajun smugglers from a gang of black men dressed in matching tribal garb, in the end of 18th century Louisiana. It feels like playing pingpong with merits and demerits on this game.

After we Assassinate the imposter Mackandal, real name Baptiste, we are introduced to a new gameplay system. The Erudito Propaganda system. The framing device of the Animus changing a scene to depict Baptiste as a tragic hero. Trying to organize a revolt against New Orleans to free the slave, being assisted by the Templars. An in-universe game called “Liberation” being a virtual reality entertainment experience presenting the Templars as the good guys and Aveline as the villain. We are, as part of the simulation, encouraged to kill the NPC in the area that allows the scene to be changed.

With the broader context of the Templars versus the Brotherhood throughout the series, a player may more easily see Assassin's Creed Liberation's framing device as an attempt at an unreliable narrator story.  Throughout the story there is constant confusion as to who is the Brotherhood and who is the Templar given that all sides seem to be on the side of freeing slaves.

The story revolves around Aveline attempting to reveal this twist. Yet I can't help but feel as though a meta-textual understanding of Assassin's Creed's modern-day framing device would be very helpful here.

While a bit haphazard and hard to follow, at best, it demonstrates, as a metanarrative, how easily the education of history can be used to propagandize an existing power structure's authority as a matter of themes.

It's now 1768, and the Spanish have taken control of New Orleans. They've erected roadblocks throughout the city, and it becomes increasingly difficult to move through the town as The Lady than before. As soon as I was given the opportunity at the end of the sequence, I switched to the Assassin's garb and proceeded to clean house. Looting every box, buying all the properties around town for changing clothes, synchronizing the entire map, and becoming a grand bourgeoisie in my own right using the shipping and trade minigame.

(I may have also used some of the downtime from the ship timers to write this article.)

Taking a moment to just play the game, rather than write about every thought and feeling coming at me with how many notable decisions were on screen, I was reminded of the simple enjoyment of the flow of these kinds of open-world games. Open-World or Ubisoft fatigue certainly is real, and this sort of icon clearing becomes arduous and compulsive at current AAA game scales. But in these smaller areas it feels more like taking the time to learn the surroundings so as to better navigate when story missions demand it. The assassinations, when they go well, are exciting to execute. But the hand to hand combat feels clunky and unintuitive.

Rather than having full control of your character from moment to moment, combat is about holding a counter stance while trying to time a perfect counter. The perfect counter slows down time and gives you a few options on the controller's face buttons for how to respond. Some enemies will be vulnerable to any of these options, but stronger enemies will counter you if you choose wrong. Followed swiftly by punching you in the face. This is poorly tutorialized in the beginning, and I didn't fully understand it until a frustrating boss fight forced me to learn the combat by trial and error.

I would be remiss, however, not to mention the shipping map, which oddly portrays the Haiti and Dominican Republic landlocked border as a channel of ocean between two islands. First for being geographically incorrect. And second for the fact that the border is not drawn there until the Dominican Republic and Haiti went to war for twelve years, 1844 to 1856, over seceding from the Republic of Haiti. 80 to 90 years after the events of the story. The line makes no sense chronologically either.

-

Now it is time to talk about Jeanne's Diary 

Throughout your time with Liberation, you will also be collecting the scattered pages of your birth mother's diary. Which tells the story of how she came into literacy despite being born a slave herself.

When infiltrating a slaving operation masquerading as an underground railroad, but in fact sending captured runaways to a mining camp in Mexico, we rescue a fleeing slave. We offer him a place in New Orleans, but he tells us he is a Fon, and plans to return to Africa. The Fon, along with the Igbo and the Yoruba, were the main cultures of West Africa that were traded in the Caribbean. He also incidentally mentions our mother due to recognizing the locket we keep with us. Telling us that she lives in this very town. And we even get the chance to meet her.

Once I completed this quest, I had all 30 pages of Jeanne's diary. So I took the time to read it, hoping to understand the intentional misunderstanding of Agaté and Baptiste.

I won't spoil the details, but the diary entries told a very compelling story of how the slaves of Saint Domingue and elsewhere were readily used as pawns by both the Brotherhood and the Templars, all while Jeanne suffered the confusing and politically wrought life of a favored house slave. An important recontextualization for me, as my experience with Odyssey and Origins taught me that the Assassins, and then the Brotherhood, would always be in heroic positions. But this was not so true in this era of Assassin's Creed.

With this, I believe I have the answer to my initial question.

-

AC3 Liberation is a fun game most of the time. There's plenty of merit for the player who just wants to play through the game for some throwback fun. There's also plenty of historical and cultural inspiration for the person who plays it for the opportunity to do some tangential learning, but the lack of time spent on the inspired elements makes it either a poor substitute for education or ample opportunity for perpetuating stereotypes.

The latter half of the game becomes more dedicated to the ongoing metanarrative of the Brotherhood and Templars conflict as necessary for understanding the character dynamics. As such, I think AC3 Liberation may only be half successful as a game trying to stand on its own merits alone.

I have long held the belief that the proper way to approach any Assassin's Creed game is not as a historical fiction, but as a historical fantasy. AC as a franchise, whenever given the choice between something more grounded and committed to historical events, or something exaggerated and bombastic, will choose bombast every time. To enjoy it, one must conscientiously provide the game with a lack of seriousness even as the games make themselves about very serious subject matter.

For these reasons I will, surprisingly, conclude that our first game in the standalone DLC series, AC3 Liberation, does qualify as an Africana Game. The game never fully loses sight of Aveline's story, and her journey to learn the truth of her family. The metanarrative may be passed over so long as you are willing to embrace the pulp-novel level of entertainment this game is geared towards. I am glad, at least, that my first experience of playing as a Haitian character in a game was Aveline de Grandpré. An immigrant, mixed race daughter of a petite bourgeois and a house slave, who became a badass and fought for the righteous cause of freedom.

Thank you for reading,

Take care of each other,

And stay true