(Bethesda is an Xbox owned game development studio, as of the March 2021 ZeniMax Media acquisition. Accessed through the Playstation Network membership service. NohPub is a participator of the BDS Boycott and the signee of the No Games For Genocide pledge. Coverage of Dishonored Death of The Outsider is made in the interest of highlighting games representation of marginal communities and critique of themes related to civil rights. See our ethics policy page for more details.)

The Standalone DLC was a 2010s model of additional content meant to smooth over the growing gaps between major franchise releases while normalizing the significantly lower costs of digital distribution. Various studios also saw it as a lower-stakes way of experimenting with new gameplay designs or ways to reach a broader audience.

There is no doubt in my mind that, among the people who made these games, there is a wide swath of inspirations and intentions.

Many established franchises took this model as an opportunity to tell stories with their respective series' first black protagonists.

Welcome to Africana Games, where I look to highlight games with black and African Diaspora main-characters. Not supporting roles nor ignorable options. And this is the DLC protagonist series. Where I play these games without experiencing their original IPs to see if they can truly stand alone. To see if they may be called Africana Games.

The next game in this series is

Dishonored: Death of the Outsider.

I'm going into this game even more blind than the two Assassin's Creed games in this series. I have only ever played Dishonored 1 in part many years ago, but haven't experienced a complete story of this game series in any capacity.

The thing I do know of Dishonored is that it is a first person game where one can either play stealthily or aggressively, and the game changes depending on your style of play. The developer, Arkane Studios, is known for making Immersive Sims. Essentially first person shooters with more flexible problem solving empowered either by in-game physics or by detailed object-oriented interactions between player-character and level design. Their game Death Loop will feature in the Africana Games series in the future. As will the upcoming Marvel's Blade if it makes it to release.

Dishonored, Death of the Outsider, presents an interesting question for the Africana Games series in particular. Can a first person game be an Africana Game?

The kneejerk answer is yes. Certainly if we may have the first person perspective of a black character, than that may be even more directly about embodying that point of view in a ludonarrative. However, let me push back on that.

My first experience with playing a black character in first person was with Player 2 of the FPS Resistance Fall of Man. In the co-op campaign, player 1 played as the named and voiced character of Sergeant Nathan Hale. The player 2 avatar is a duplicate of the player 1 character, whose skin tone has been darkened, has no name, and is not mentioned in the historical framing device of the narrative. You would only notice by having player 1 look at the player 2 avatar.

It takes my work as a critic to give this perspective its own value as an accurate portrayal of how black people are written out of their contributions of history; empowered by my college friends joking at the game's inept stumbling into racism, back in those dorms years ago.

One criterion for being an Africana Game is that blackness is not ignorable. And that is at risk with a first person perspective.

A pair of gloves. A non-black voice actor. A lack of stereotypical gesturing and black manners of speech. Suddenly nothing you do can keep the character being black within the frame. Meaning the player who desires to ignore the character in favor of the function of gameplay may more easily do so.

But I wouldn't call it impossible. Hands may be black. Speech may incorporate and portray culture without offensive stereotypes. Even well executed hand-acting like we saw in games like the Doom reboot series. These tools are available for those who know how to use them, or make a devoted study of the culture.

After playing through the first mission, it becomes clear that the team at Arkane isn't thinking about that as a priority. Between the hard boiled dialogue and the comic panel cutscenes in a heavily English coded city, it's clear that we're here for a fun time. Not an interesting time.

And y'know what? That's okay. Not every story with a black protagonist is meant to be South of Midnight. Between the menu portraiture and the illustrations at the end of each mission, I don't think we're looking at a situation where the protagonist character may be ignored. At least, not for very long.

So it's time to move on to embracing the game as it is;

it's time for review.

Immediately we can say that lore and preamble are rushed. Again, understandable given that the expectation is that the player has already experienced the main game. To a certain extent, however, I appreciate this. Dialogue that drops you in the middle of a world unlike ours. Everyone involved knows who the Outsider is. It isn’t strange for Billie that she can hear the voices of the rats.

And when our mentor Daud tells us we are going to kill the Outsider, Billie saying, “We're going to kill God?” Well that's all we need to know about the kind of task being laid in front of us.

That sort of kinetic pacing is refreshing. Given that so much of my recent experience with fantasy genre media has involved an outpouring of jargon and proper nouns that actively hinder narrative development.

Even the original Dishonored had a much more gradual introduction.

This put me right in the action. Quite literally, because of my own lack of observation and familiarity with Immersive Sims, I didn't spy most of my options. Wound up kiting enemies into narrow spaces and pounding health items to make it through the first mission. Despite my best efforts to be stealthy.

Gonna try a bit harder on the next one.

The game immediately opens up here. The titular Outsider we are trying to kill ambushes us in a vision. Giving us powers and a ghostly, skeletal hand. The powers we are given are:

  • Displace: teleporting to a nearby location 

  • Foresight: surveying the area as a disembodied spirit.

  • Semblance: non-lethally taking down an enemy and stealing their appearance.

These three abilities opened up so many options for me. Far more useful than the telepathy that lets you understand the thoughts of rats.

Displace allowed me to travel the levels across rooftops, staying out of sight of the various guards who would attack me. Semblance allowed for easier takedowns with more time to make sure I'm executing my plan correctly. But Foresight was by far my favorite.

Being able to scan the space in front of me, mark guards, and formulate a plan. Rather than just reacting to the chaos I found in that first level. Foresight has a very limited timer. So I intuitively used it in two ways. To get a very detailed look at the room ahead. Or rushing around quickly to get a glance at the whole space.

For example, in the famous singer Shan Yun's mansion, I used foresight to quickly rush through the foyer, mark three guards, fly through the kitchen, notice a key worn on a servant's hip, before reaching a dead end to spy a healing item in a safe.

Only after taking in a rush of information did I then look forward and figure out how I wanted to approach this challenge. Truly unlocking an active way to be more observant of the environment and how to traverse it.

Which is, in a word, exactly what the Immersive Sim genre is all about.

Death of The Outsider also puts forward themes critiquing the prison industrial complex. Ivan Yacobi is a local politician whose office we raid in our search for a magical knife that may kill The Outsider. He is giving a speech in the public square on the inhumanity of Regraving, the act of excavating and relocating graveyards for the sake of urban development.

He is practicing a speech in a local courtyard, and we manage to steal a key off his person to access his private office. He's a high ranking member of the Eyeless cult, possessing another key to the location of the magic dagger we need.

In his office is a book, Whispers From The Void by Barnoli Mulani, who suggests prisoners be used, in cooperation with the corrupt Abbie which raised Billie and the Academy of Natural Philosophy, to run experiments on how to access the realm of the dead. Comparing prisoners to rats.

Which, thanks to Billie's telepathic connection to the Rats of the city, must feel like a personal attack.

One such method we may see on the top floor of the Spectator club, who are directly transfusing the blood of a still living prison into themselves before wrapping up the spent bodies and tossing them in a closet.

The politician, happy to boast about protecting the rights of the dead, can't manage to see the living humans at the margins of society as people at all. 

These themes of who deserves to live or to die, and why, run throughout the story and its gameplay decisions. More or less violent approaches to completing missions offer different answers to those questions. Nor is it as simple as a gameplay exchange of killing being more expedient but less moral. As is typically the case in stealth games that explore ethical themes. Non-violence may be the less moral choice when faced with brutal, corrupt, and immoral enemies, while being far easier in the gameplay. The duality of violence and mercy, of justice and freedom, of death and life, run through to the final choice presented in the game's title.

I was about ready to wrap up this review with a gleaming recommendation for Dishonored Death of the Outsider. The shorter length given by the standalone DLC model affording the game a AAA level quality without the AAA level bloat that typically accompanies it. Particularly from an era before AAA came to be defined by the layering of predatory monetization schemes into every design. Though there were also plenty of times when I interacted with something in the environment or used a tool in my arsenal, and received no feedback about what it did to change the situation. 

Then, I ran into the game Falcon Age by Outer Loop Games. I was on the developer's Steam Profile Page, looking into Dos Divas and Thirsty Suitors as potential candidates for this series. Falcon Age is a first person, action adventure with a gimmick of being a falconer to a magical bird companion.

The protagonist of the game, as depicted in the promotional banner art, is giving the dark skinned protagonist a fantasy Mediterranean feel. And the first thing the trailer shows is cute hand-acting of the protagonist playing with their young falcon.

As I said earlier, hands are the first and only tool a first person game really has to sell the character of its protagonist. Dishonored's Billie Lurk has a voice, she has a face. She is a strong example of a black woman protagonist in a popular franchise. … But she doesn't have her hands.

She has a glove and magic limb given to her by an evil ghost called The Outsider.

I have nothing negative to say about Dishonored Death of The Outsider, but am I asking for too little when I don't ask for her hands, the thing we see for the entirety of the game, to be a black person's hands?

I am looking forward to playing Arkane Studios’ Death Loop. I will sort out my feelings then.

Thank you for reading,

Take care of each other,

And stay true.