Content warning: discussion of suicide and suicidal ideation. If you are in the United States and contemplating suicide, please call the National Suicide & Crisis Lifeline by dialing 988. Seek out friends or family, and ask for help. You are not alone.

Ryuunosuke Akutagawa was one of the most celebrated Japanese authors of the early 20th century.

Whose short stories of his early career caught the attention of Japan’s most highly acclaimed writer, Natsume Souseki. Akutagawa's ability to combine Japanese classicism with the more modern, personal, and individualistic perspectives of his Western literature studies excited the literary world for the future of Japanese Lit.

Through darker themes and emphasis on character perspective, Akutagawa would have been heralded as the next great author of his age. That is until his writings after Rashomon and In The Grove failed to capture an audience. Akutagawa's personal and professional life struggled. And in 1927, at the young age of 35, Ryuunosuke Akutagawa died of suicide. https://www.britannica.com/biography/Akutagawa-Ryunosuke 

Ryuunosuke Akutagawa was the favorite author of one Osamu Dazai.

Dazai was a mid 20th-century fiction author who prioritized autobiographical fiction. Which is, to say, taking the events of one's own life and changing them into the plot points of fictional characters. How Dazai embraced vices and suffering: drinking, drug use, prostitution. How his misogyny manifested as a simultaneous Madonna-Whore Complex with the women in his company. Self-pity and childish innocence interwoven with violence and abuse. These were what made a Dazai novel unique. https://www.craftliterary.com/2020/05/12/extremely-disorganized-life-peter-selgin/ 

Today we would consider such writing to be closer to personal essay than fiction. Upon Akutagawa's suicide, the disturbing and straightforward subject matter of Dazai's self-destructive lifestyle became the main subject of Dazai's novels. Until his eventual death of suicide in 1948. A double-suicide with his mistress then wife Tomai Yamazaki.

These narratives of abject tragedy would not be assumed to be the stuff of popular literature. Nonetheless, Dazai's work was revered in his time for its artistry, honesty, and vulnerability. The annual literature award named after him is one of the more prestigious accolades in Japanese literature.

These were not the only cases of prominent Japanese authors with prestigious careers dying young to the disease of suicide.

Both novels and novelists of the 20th century idolized and romanticized suicide quite frequently in Japan.

These stories are identified by the genre/trope Shinju 心中. Written with the kanji for Heart and the kanji for Center. Descending from the bunraku plays of Chikamatsu Monzaemon. Stories of true love coming into conflict with social expectations and propriety. https://metropolisjapan.com/why-do-so-many-japanese-love-stories-end-in-double-suicide/

Silent Hill: The Short Message, is about the romanticization of suicide.

It is Shinju. It is the story of three friends: Maya, Amelie, and Anita.

Or, at least, it appears to be Shinju for the majority of its two hour runtime. It even references a certain book whose author took their own life when they were very young. Without naming the book nor the author, the audience is expected to think of either Akutagawa or Dazai.

Silent Hill The Short Message is entirely about drawing from the philosophies behind aesthetic values, critiquing them when those philosophies are applied to people, and finally asserting that people retain their value even in the face of horror.

Let's start with the game's primary motif, among many.

Sakura flowers.

Cherry Blossoms are a favored aesthetic imagery in Japan for two reasons. First because of the abundance of cherry trees throughout the country, often attributed to efforts of Shogun Tokugawa Yoshimune to propagate cherry trees throughout Edo in the early 18th century. For the sake of a cultural festival practice called Hanami. Flower Viewing. An annual festival for witnessing the Sakura Trees bloom for 1 week in a year. https://japantoday.com/category/features/travel/asukayama-among-the-shoguns-blossoms 

The second reason is Buddhism. Zen artistic practices frequently tried to capture the Buddhist idea of all reality being transient and illusory. From that developed the Japanese artistic value of WabiSabi. https://nomurakakejiku.com/lesson_lineup/wabi-and-sabi 

Wabi meaning wretchedness and poverty. Sabi meaning deterioration due to time. The combination of these terms into an artistic aesthetic was to highlight flaws and damage as that which reveals the impermanence of all things. Reminding us to reflect on the teachings of Buddha, and thereby finding beauty not in the illusion of aesthetics, but in transience itself. Things are beautiful because they are temporary. Because they are short-lived.

Once you understand this value, you understand the character of Maya's art. She is applying WabiSabi to people. Much like Kintsugi, the practice of highlight cracks in ceramics with gold lacquer, Maya was highlighting the physical and emotional trauma of people who committed suicide with Sakura Flowers.

Not exactly the same as the rock-n-roll idea of “live free and die young”. But by often vocally idolizing the idea of achieving some peak moment of beauty before choosing to die, Maya is actively losing sight of other Zen values. Like Kokou, Austerity, which is the beauty of age and experience. Or Seijaku, Tranquility, the beauty of passively accepting the natural processes of change.

The Short Message of Silent Hill was the beauty of transience. Ultimately Maya's character wasn't acting on others so much as projecting her art onto them, so as to feel less alone. She didn't receive the help she needed at a pivotal time. She may have attempted to ask her friend Amelie to engage in a double-suicide, but her letter never made it. Due to Anita, though motivated by a selfish attachment, lashing out at Maya.

Beyond the motif of the Sakura Flowers, there is the motif of Graffiti. Maya's chosen medium for illustration.

The first and most common type of graffiti art is when a person simply writes their own name on a public wall. 

Perhaps accompanied by the words “was here.” Graffiti is often compared to a desperate attempt at being immortalized through art. An attempt to be remembered.

Graffiti is often a criminal activity classified as vandalism. It cannot be practiced openly, and is thereby often an impulsive activity to create or communicate in the moment of opportunity. Due to the social circumstances around graffiti, the format is almost always A Short Message.

Which is why the ability to expand that artform into illustration is so impressive. Using tools like spray paint, designed for broad architectural finishing more so than precision; finishing pieces quickly so as to not be caught or punished for artistic expression. A blank concrete wall is bare at sunset, and beautiful at sunrise. The artform reveals a sturdy wall to be transient, subject to change.

To create extensive illustration on public walls is its own artistic feat, unique from other kinds of painting.

The setting of the German town Kettenstadt, however, creates a unique relationship to the art form of graffiti. Due to bloated real-estate development from the sub-prime mortgage bundling schemes which caused the 2008 global economic crash, Kettenstadt is filled with abandoned and derelict high-rise apartments.

These walls are already transient in their decay.

Transforming these spaces into the perfect haven for loitering, hooliganism, and practicing graffiti. 

Within the first room where you can read about this history from a discarded newspaper, there is a graffiti mural of a man pulling apart prison bars to view a bright, blue sky. Careful inspection of the bottom of the mural reveals that the bars are actually a bar-code for a retail's point of sale. Communicating that freedom can only be achieved by abandoning the expectations of capital or profit within this town that has no hope of economic recovery.

Throughout the villa, the graffiti expresses a pretty even split between murals trying to express hope in a better tomorrow, and others trying to express anger, suffering, and personal trauma.

The graffiti is an argument between different artists. A public display of people trying to reach out to the people climbing to the villa's roof. Some trying to reflect the pain being experienced. Others trying to convince them not to jump. 

Throughout act one of the game, the player can review each of the murals freely, and Anita discusses them in the context of an artist's death bringing fame and popularity to their work. That death makes a person's work permanent and memorable. Maya's follower count on Twitter keeps going up, while Anita, as a small creator and a teenage girl, continues to be bullied, insulted, and sexually harassed whenever she tries to communicate her feelings.

But graffiti is ephemeral.

As a public art form, graffiti is conversational. Text is responded to with more text. Murals with an artist's tag at the bottom are met with other tags trying to steal the valor of the illustration for themselves. Pictures are often edited to create sarcastic or ironic irreverence for the original. In act 3, Anita finds Maya's murals desecrated. Covered in insults. 

Graffiti is a short-form, anonymous, public, communicative art form where conversations take place over days, weeks, years, and decades. Fueled by impulse and reaction, alongside the opportunity for robust creation and connection.

Graffiti is a Social Media.

The second historical backdrop of the game is the COVID-19 Pandemic.

Seems trite to summarize considering everyone here experienced it. But let's do it anyway. COVID-19 was a novel mutation of a coronavirus that caused a global pandemic that developed at the end of 2019. Due to its rate of propagation, the significant mortality rate of the viral infection, and the time needed to create a vaccine, the global strategy for containment and public safety were social distancing, state mandated lockdowns and quarantines, state policies of sheltering in your home and limiting travel, and masking when in public spaces.

All social health measures were highly politicized. Conspiracy theories, blame, and fear mongering was commonplace. Including the propagation of anti-vaccine sentiment and conspiracy, due to severe loss of confidence in public health from inconsistent public messaging. Seeing how quickly a vaccine can be produced, when the global economic incentive requires a free social good to be created for everyone, created suspicion.

People didn't believe capitalist society would or could.

Depending on where you live, the public health policies rolled back between May of 2023 and the end of 2024. 

Social media flourished as a nexus for entertainment and conflict; the world was a captured audience.

But what many don't consider is that full length of time. 3 to 5 years. Some teenagers spent their entire formative years, their entire high-school experience, in their homes and on social media.

Not an option among many in terms of how to have a social life. It simply was society. All friendships and new connections filtered through short-form text and the ratings metrics of likes and shares. Opinions were not private. Every statement was measured and commodified by their platforms.

It is easy to consider social media trite and unimportant, especially now as more and more people divest from social media interaction as a conscientious lifestyle choice. The vast majority of users are bot accounts interacting with other bots.

But in the context of a certain generation's historical perspective, social media is society.

Silent Hill The Short Message visually represents this with the physical analogue of sticky notes. Another, short-form, social, and ephemeral means of pre-internet communication. Either leaving notes for yourself or for others. To be discarded after their use.

As the game progresses, surfaces become progressively covered in post-it notes each with a hostile phrase or insult. Both in-game and in the FMV sections.

Not literally notes, but a metaphorical representation of Anita's state of mind. Bullying that happened both when she was in-school, and which followed her online during covid. Trying to subconsciously communicate to players of other generations the feeling of omnipresence of social media for those who aren't familiar with it.

One graffiti illustration you may find is a happy family of three: mother, father, and child. Their heads are covered in black garbage bags. Smiling faces have been scribbled over them. The father wears a rosary. The child holds a skateboard. The caption reads “suffocate family.”

This mural is communicating a dynamic of domestic bonds feeling like a limit on freedom, using death as the metaphor for that restriction, and alluding to Christianity potentially being related to what moral code may be at odds with the child's current self expression. The smiling faces present a performative happiness to meet social expectations. While also reflecting the curated self-image that comes with social media. 

These are not uncommon feelings and insecurities for a teenager to have. But for Anita, the sound of a crying baby in the air, heard when you first leave the room and may see the mural, and the future trash bags found in her apartment later in the game, means the mural reflects her personal traumatic history of domestic neglect before the player has a chance to learn of it.

A meaning not intended by the original artist is being triggered in Anita by reminding her of past trauma. As one may experience scrolling through a social media feed.

The entire game is communicated through short-form, transient media like this.

A hallmark of the Silent Hill games is that they always center communication technology in some fashion. Radios that warn you of nearby monsters. Telephones for saving your game. Television screens and polaroid pictures. Public transit.

Silent Hill The Short Message's technology is texting. What else could it be?

Texting has fundamentally changed how daily communication works in the world. Friends no longer have to call to speak with each other at a distance. Conversations no longer need a beginning, middle, and end at a set time or location the way they were with landline phones.

With unlimited texting, conversations become an ongoing flow of a few short sentences. Something comes to mind or you think of the person, it takes 5 seconds to reach out. Paradoxically, because of the shortness and the convenience of a text, text conversations can go for hours, days, or even weeks.

Without taking away time from other activities, all texting can happen in found moments of downtime. And turns out even extremely busy people have a lot of free time for texting.

The ease of texting also comes with a social pressure. Because you can always be available, you must be. Failure to respond evokes the criticism of leaving a person “on read.”

In an environment when these digital interactions are the only social dynamic that exists, environments like a pandemic lockdown, not responding is the equivalent of abandonment. It's leaving your friend at a bar without letting them know. It's standing-up a date when your friend is already at the theatre.

The Text is a Social Media.

The casual dynamic of the text has also shifted how people think about calls. Texting for hours is typically lighthearted. A surprise or delight. Only veering into the personal at times, by providing a space with less social performance. Meaning calls become for times of significance or importance, exclusively. Calls are for when texting is inappropriate or insensitive.

We see calls, now, as reasons for anxiety and fear.

When we receive a call, we are apt to forego saying, “Hello,” and skip immediately to, “What's wrong?” “What Happened?” “Are you okay?”

We brace. And if reassured the conversation can continue normally. Else the call takes all attention out of the room. We dedicate ourselves to the person on the other end.

When Anita calls Amelie, it is only in her worst moments, on the roof of the villa.

The final media represented in the game, is a letter. A suicide letter. Maya's last attempt to reach out, that wasn't delivered in time to intervene. In a way, it is the longest and slowest means of communication depicted in the game. She writes it because Amelie wrote her letters.

Anita spends a good portion of the game texting with her friend Amelie. The smartphone's flashlight is your main source of light when exploring dark halls. So when a text comes in, it's clearly in view. And we respond immediately.

Anita never considers the option of leaving a text unanswered.

When she calls for help, Amelie responds. When the call concludes, Amelie refuses to let the conversation end. Just in time to get through to her friend, and clear the fog. 

The Short Message is a short game. Only 2 hours long. It is a game made out of short messages. And when it was released, the game was critically and popularly lambasted online.

As the first Silent Hill to be released after the cancellation of Silent Hills and the removal of P.T. from storefronts, social media expectations for The Short Message were sky high.

The base game was free, but people found it worth criticizing the deluxe edition. Charging the then standard $70 dollars US. Due to the low value proposition of a 2 hour game.

The story was panned for being out of touch, boomer pessimism about social media. It was ridiculed for the saccharine ending saying a text message can cure suicidal ideation. I will personally admit that I did find the dialogue to be forced at times. And comparatively the game is not as frightening as most contemporary horror games. But these broad oversimplifications of the game's themes simply aren't true.

You'll have noticed that throughout this critique, I have not highlighted the specifics of the domestic and social traumas the three main characters experienced. And this was done with intent.

The game makes it important to the characters and the history of the setting to bring attention to how the pandemic exacerbated the suffering of people experiencing domestic abuse. It is the only theme of the game that isn't presented as being worsened or caused by social media. And highlights that communication technology is neither being praised nor vilified.

It is merely being recognized for the unique forms they bring to real traumatic experiences.

The Short Message is a shinju that seeks to deny shinju. To deny the romanticization of suicide. But to draw out of shinju what people find so appealing about these stories.

When the Shinju genre grew in popularity, the Japanese government sought to censor these books. To blame them for the rise of suicide rates in Japan in the 20th century.

Today, we disincentivize discussion of suicide through platform demonetization and algorithmic censorship. The slang of Unaliving developed out of the DeadPool movie has a permanent place in the modern lexicon because of censorship.

We fear that speaking it will make it real.

And the result is that people suffering feel as though they have no place to speak. They are left feeling strange, alone, and isolated for thinking about what is socially forbidden to speak.

I'll tell you what my mother said to me, when I was a suicidal teenager. She said, “I think every smart person in the world has thought about suicide.” And when she said this to me, I didn't feel alone.

I felt weird, but not alone.

Every act of the game begins and ends with information for contacting the suicide prevention hotline. Every moment of the game is encouraging you to talk about it, while validating how hard that is to do.

It's showing how many ways there are to talk about suicide, how technology and the arts can be used to talk about it.

Because talking to someone will save so many more lives than pretending we don't think about suicide.

Reach out and talk to someone. You are not alone.

That's the message.

And I think that it’s one worth saying.

The need to speak the truth in your heart. No matter how it sounds, and no matter how much it hurts. Only to be silenced before you ever say a word. That is how a Short Message, Becomes Horror.

Thank you for reading,

Take care of each other,

And Stay True.


Speak with someone today

988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline

Languages: English, Spanish

Hours: 24/7