Silent Hill Townfall is oozing with style.

The technological achievement of realism in one hand, where the buildings, roads, and interiors place you perfectly in a diorama of a small, Scottish town. 

In the other hand, dynamic and graphic expressionism. Blinding lights of primary colors set to jarring sounds that fill the heart with dread. Text across the screen becomes thought as it echoes both quiet contemplation of the prefrontal cortex and the panicked urgency of the limbic system.

Drawing, I believe, from the cinematic aesthetics of Signalis as a main source of inspiration.

Silent Hill Townfall opens, best to say, confusingly. A man bursts out of the sea water and onto a dock in the small Scottish town of St. Amelia.

An IV bag is strapped to our arm, but it's too painful to remove the needle. All the businesses are closed, and their properties and storefronts are all for sale by a small handful of real estate agents.

Through an obsessive reading of the signs on East Coast Road, and the metaphorical media literacy of a decade-old essayist, within the esoteric aesthetics was a pretty clear narrative.

Here is the story, as I predicted, upon completing the opening chapter of the game. Simon was an employee of CEQ, the energy corporation servicing this fishing town. An oil rig was built off the coast, and Simon was managing employees at either the company or within a trade union.

There was an accident on the oil rig. Most of the men working died. Simon survived, and traumatized by the event, is feeling extreme survivors’ guilt.

The remaining workers, the families of the diseased, and the whole town banded together to demand reparations, but CEQ refused.

Tensions escalated. Protests were organized. But CEQ refused to listen. It had a monopoly of energy in this town. They didn't need to agree to demands.

Protests developed into a hunger strike. The state stepped in. Forcibly removing non-violent protestors to a facility where they may be force-fed to keep the company from experiencing more liability.

The glaring red light of Simon's hallucinations mirror the emergency alarms and flares they used to call for help, continuing to be unheeded after the accident.

I record this theory not as a way of praising myself if it turns out to be true, but merely to praise the game for the detail of its environment and atmosphere. I can confidently say a few of those predictions were wrong.

St. Amelia’s feels lived in. The town feels from the era just before the turn to the internet age. Scottish and Irish reviewers have pointed to how the details reflect the architecture and technology of the time. Down to the use of pre-paid cards for home electricity meters, or the exact models of telephones, televisions, and ATMs that were specific models from that region of the world in the ending years of the 20th century.

This story is experienced through the tangibility of its tools. Main Character Simon's Compact Radio Television is your primary lifeline, but it is noticeably not streamlined. It allows you to observe enemies by turning to their frequency, and pointing your camera to track their movements. Only one creature can be observed at a time.

Tuning for frequencies, fine tuning to weaker signals or adjusting the color balance of the display using gyro controls. Even the folding and turning of the map to reference the legend. All contribute to the feeling of being embodied with the main character.

This feeling expands as we move to the second main character of the game, Zoe Ellis. 

Due to the disaster, Zoe Ellis, as a full time nurse, has been moved from overworked to only worked. Working 12 hours shifts, 7 days a week, for more than a month, as the mainland government refuses to allow both regular staff and relief workers to come to St. Amelia's Medical Center. 

As a nurse in the 90s, with a traditional, misogynistic doctor as the hospital's Chief of Medicine, she has internalized the criticisms and insults.  She believes all failures to be her own. Lacking the will needed to speak out when she is coerced into committing medical malpractice outside of her scope.

The CRTV is replaced with Zoe's pager in these sections. The perimeter of the pager replaces the spy-glass function of the CRTV with a proximity censor. Keeping the demands and harassment of her bosses and coworkers in sight at all times.

What the pager lacks in specificity with an enemy's distance and direction, it gains in the ability to show the locations of multiple enemies at once.

This creates two gameplay flows, each with a unique take on the stealth-horror genre. Simon who uses weapons and greater single-target information to avoid some enemies and to pick off others. Whereas Zoe's sections present extremely tight problem solving. Using noise-making environmental objects and hiding spots to narrowly flee the beast around the corner.

In either case. A failure results in a high-stakes chase. Running for your life as you break for the next objective.

Walking a narrow line between the disempowerment horror of the Amnesia series, and the combat of typical survival horror.

While I did hear some talk of people disliking the stealth for being purely waiting games, I never found this to be the case.

One encounter did have significantly more waiting, and planning, around a singular enemy with a complex pattern and no possible hope of combat. 

In these circumstances, if a survival horror game provides the option of combat, I prefer that the choice to engage is a real choice. Which one must make at the significant loss of resources and potential loss of progress. However, I also truly loved the complexity of this encounter. Because it allowed me to flex my geospatial reasoning.

Able to track movement and depth across the 2D layout of the paper map was quite doable after the many hours I've spent as a hiking enthusiast. Keeping track of my cardinal directions no matter the day or location by pure habit. It felt like a dilemma specifically made for me.

Though one criticism I do have are the puzzles that require some outside knowledge to reasonably solve. Similar to the above mentioned pre-paid electricity card, one puzzle required basic knowledge of normalized ranges of vital signs. The game does provide the clues needed to discern the correct answers, but having my nurse-wife at my side made this section a breeze.

These puzzles still add significant depth, a sense of place, and a sense of solidarity with the characters. But nevertheless veer on the side of immersion-breaking frustration.

Though take my perspective here with a grain of salt. As I am a notorious puzzle-hater willing to distinguish a puzzle from more general terms like problem-solving and dilemmas.

For the player who embraces this, they are in for a, quite literally, visceral sense of empathy as Simon and Zoe's shared abuse at the hands of uncaring and negligent systems bonds them together with the shackles of unearned guilt, responsibility, and shame. 

Of all the horror games I've played since beginning this series, Townfall understands the importance of setting, atmosphere, and empathy better than all the rest, and snatches them away before you have a moment to breath.

Townfall is the fallout that comes from survival. The belief, the certainty, that you could or should have, even when all rationality says the threat was beyond your control, done more. That is how a simple, working-class town off the coast of Scotland, Becomes Horror.

Thank you for reading,

Take care of each other,

And stay true.