By: Alexander Holmes
(This article was written and finalized before the Jacob Geller SA case came to light. This video is not an endorsement nor diminishing the severity of the situation.)
So I just rolled credits on The Last Guardian. . .
I had intended to play this game long ago, and I'm glad to have finally gotten around to that mythical sequel to Ico and Shadow of the Colossus. I really am. But I'm having a lot of feelings about the game right now. And sad to say that the main feeling is disappointment.
But i don't want to say that the game is bad. Through the art, sound design, and programming, I can see that the game succeeded at its own artistic intent. So I'm trying to understand why I'm feeling so dissatisfied.
Terrible Controls
Terrible Camera
So many resets due to a jump not working
I think the primary reason is the feeling of movement. The stiffness of the character movement, camera, and climbing are all either too unresponsive or paradoxically too aggressive.
The movement, climbing, and jumping all felt unresponsive. Aiming the shield-light in the early game was unwieldy. And on multiple occasions where the game took control of the camera and slowed the game for big cinematics moments, I would simply fall to my death for unknown reasons. Perhaps it was simply because the jump before that moment was timed incorrectly, or I didn't hold a direction on the stick for long enough during the slow-mo scene that felt like I wasn't in control of the moment. Between failures and successes, I wouldn't be able to tell you what was done wrong. And, having just beaten Shadow of the Colossus again before i started, this isn't how Wander or Aggro felt in that game.
The camera whips around and auto-focuses on points of interest in ways that actively fought my ability to look at and inspect the environment. Which, for a linear puzzle platformer, I feel is also a serious detriment to not just game feel, but also game design. The camera refocusing on Trico's position at all times often hindered my ability to observe the puzzle before me and identify how to progress forward through the game.
These factors combined to make the moment to moment feeling of being in the world feel bad. Which means my motivation to continue playing the game was more and more sustained by my external desire to educate myself on the experience of the game as a piece of art.
The programming for Trico is clearly extraordinary as an accomplishment. Through careful programming they achieved an NPC that feels like a living animal with preferences and feelings. But the lack of responsiveness overstays its welcome. If a puzzle solution is known, and directed with the proper controls, but Trico instead walks in and out of the same cave 5 times before being positioned just-so, in those moments Trico feels like programming. And not that immersion is everything for a game, but i feel like immersion is quite important for a game like this.
And that repetitiveness shows itself not just when the game falters, but also when it's experienced as intended. As you progress, less than halfway through the game, you will have seen all of the controls, puzzles, challenges, and cinematic moments the game has to offer. Making investment in the story all that's left to you.
So, having finished the game myself, and left to wonder, “Why haven't a seen any video essays about the end of The Last Guardian?” I've seen plenty on stark moments in the middle. I've seen plenty of videos about the end of Shadow of the Colossus. And I've seen Jacob's video on The Last Guardian too. I waited six years before playing The Last Guardian, long enough to forget that video entirely. And that's the only one I've seen about how The Last Guardian ends.
I've seen more videos about Ico's cover art and the mechanic of holding hands than on Last Guardian's ending. Why?
I rolled credits, and I think I have the answer.
The Last Guardian leaves no mysteries.
What got me interested in these games in the first place was Jacob Geller's video on the last secret of Shadow of the Colossus. I had played Ico before, borrowed from a friend in college, but it didn't make an impression on me back then. I was in my Skyrim, Nier, and Catherine fandom phases at the time. Ico just seemed simplistic.
The Last Guardian gives that same feeling. Singularly Beautiful and impressive in ways no other game achieves, but still simplistic. And this extends to the story.
The narration throughout creates a story telling device that ensures the player knows they will survive any threat. Transforming any harrowing moment that doesn't result, into simply loading a checkpoint for a story that just lost narrative tension.
The last few cutscenes present enough information for most players to come up with an explanatory narrative, even if our head canons don't agree.
What really solidified this feeling in my head was looking at the Blue Doors that are dotted throughout the game. I kept seeing those doors brightly contrasting the dark and grey stones around them, and it gave me that feeling that there is something in this world left to discover.
Shadow of the Colossus had this feeling in spades. Any path felt like it may lead to some sacred grove or secret pond. People scoured its map for collectibles and spent years trying to glide on birds or climb the temple. Everyone turned around and climbed to the top of the spiral staircase from the opening cutscene at least once. And while the only reward available was the artistry of the environment design, that never detracted from how the world felt.
Then, near the final level of the game, it happened. I was grabbed by one of the stone guardians of the temple near one of those blue doors. It opened, a swirling vortex of energy inside. I escaped. I ran. I was safe, and astounded at what I just saw. And then I realized… the blue doors are just fail states. It's a game over that resets the checkpoint. Its no different from falling off a ledge.
It wasn't a mystery anymore.
What followed were all the game's final cutscenes. And I just kept thinking, “the game is explaining itself.”
Now i know what those cages do. Now i know why i have those markings. Now I know what the barrels are. Now i know where the stone guardian come from. Now i know how the shield works. Now I know what the tomb at the bottom of the tower was for.
And I never actually wanted to know. I wanted to wonder.
The mystery is what kept me playing. And without it, the resolution told me that I need not return. This adventure is well and truly finished.
Even the ending has a final, post-credits stinger that leaves us with an even happier ending. Quite unlike the bittersweet ending of Colossus. One that leaves us with a sense of relief, yet even greater questions. The first ending where Trico merely leaves would have been better left on its own. Rewinding the clock to see Trico one more time means little when I know he is safe and free.
The format of the linear platform adventure reduces the urge to explore and seek out discovery as a core engagement. Even as stages wrap back around themselves, Guardian is clearly moving through bespoke levels with bespoke solutions, and occasional combat. It has more in common with Uncharted than Colossus or Ico.
Would I have been more moved by this game if it came before I became a cat dad? The real-world intuition I've developed for understanding the needs, emotions, and communications of my cats, Jazz and Calypso, are infinitely more complex than anything which could be programmed in a game. If I had still that longing to develop an emotional connection like I have with my pets, would Guardian have succeeded on delivering the Pathos is so clearly wanted to provide?
There is no occasion to wonder about the mystery of this world. One may safely explain the entire story, and even head-canon our way to Guardian being geographically nearby the mysterious peninsula of Colossus. But I will never be left to wonder anything more about the setting.
The Last Guardian is a puzzle platformer that solves itself. And because of that, I don't find my mind wandering back to its world as I had done for Shadow of the Colossus. And that, the wonder, ultimately, is what's missing.
Thank you for watching,
Take care of each other,
And stay true
